Compare solar proposals using energy assumptions, not panel count alone

Normalize two hypothetical proposals by array size, inverter size and annual yield before comparing them.

By Kyle Bell · Original examples and linked primary references · November 17, 2026

Two solar proposals can give different production estimates even when their headline system sizes look similar. A useful comparison separates the physical equipment from the model assumptions. Start with DC array capacity, AC inverter capacity, annual AC energy, monthly energy and the assumptions used to calculate them. Ask for missing information instead of inferring it from a single large annual number.

Normalize array size

Consider two fictional proposals. Proposal A has fifteen 400 W panels: 15 × 400 ÷ 1,000 = 6 kW DC. Proposal B has twenty 350 W panels: 20 × 350 ÷ 1,000 = 7 kW DC. The panel count alone does not express the same capacity because the individual ratings differ.

If both proposals use 5 kW AC of inverter capacity, their DC/AC ratios are 6 ÷ 5 = 1.2 and 7 ÷ 5 = 1.4. Those ratios describe the relationship between two power ratings. They do not directly give an annual clipping percentage or show which system has a better financial outcome.

Compare annual energy per installed kilowatt

Assume Proposal A estimates 8,200 kWh per year and Proposal B estimates 9,000 kWh. The second estimate is 800 kWh, or about 9.76%, higher. Yet B has 16.67% more DC capacity. Specific yield helps make this difference visible:

A: 8,200 ÷ 6 = 1,366.7 kWh per kW DC per year.

B: 9,000 ÷ 7 = 1,285.7 kWh per kW DC per year.

The lower specific yield does not prove that B is a poor design. Its panels may use a less favorable roof plane, or the assumptions may differ. The point is to identify the question: why does each installed kilowatt contribute a different annual amount? Compare the roof areas and modeling inputs before drawing a conclusion.

Ask how inverter limits were modeled

SAM's system-design documentation describes limiting inverter output when the available input exceeds the inverter's capacity. How much energy is affected depends on the time profile, not just the DC/AC ratio. A 1.4 ratio does not mean 40% annual energy loss.

A simple monthly arithmetic calculator cannot recreate hourly clipping. If a proposal includes modeled clipping losses, keep that output alongside its hourly-model assumptions. Do not try to reproduce it by capping annual kWh at an inverter's kW rating; those are different units. For this comparison worksheet, record inverter capacity as context rather than pretending that it alone determines annual generation.

Make the rest of the assumptions comparable

Request the source and period of the weather data, the modeled tilt and direction for each roof plane, shading treatment, equipment-loss assumptions and whether energy is measured before or after inverter conversion. Record whether a claimed production figure is a model estimate or a separately defined contractual guarantee.

The PVWatts introduction describes its estimates as preliminary and recommends qualified professional assessment for final design. A proposal comparison should preserve the same distinction: a transparent estimate helps ask better questions, but it does not replace inspection of the property and equipment design.

Finally, compare monthly output with the household's consumption and utility terms. Two arrays with similar annual generation can have different value if their output occurs at different times. Save a worksheet with the original quote date, ratings, annual and monthly estimates, assumptions and unanswered questions. That record is more useful than selecting the proposal with the largest panel count or the most optimistic unlabeled number.

Keep learning

Solar kW vs kWh: turn a panel rating into an energy estimate